The Strategic Pivot: How to Know When to Pivot Your Business Model (Without Losing Everything)

Feeling the urge to pivot but scared to blow up everything you’ve built? Here’s how to recognize the signs, test your ideas, and shift strategically.

After three major career transformations in three years—corporate executive to leadership coach and author, then expanding into hotel sourcing, and finally focusing primarily on hotel sourcing and event strategy—I've learned what makes pivots successful versus disastrous. Each transition improved my quality of life dramatically. My income dipped during the changes—going from multiple six figures to rebuilding—but I'm now back to that level, doing work that energizes rather than exhausts me.

If you're feeling that restless energy that says "something needs to change"—what I call "the whispers" in my book "The Cost of Staying"—you’re not alone. That internal tug is common. What matters is how you respond to it.

But I didn't just wing it—I learned to recognize specific signals and developed a process that made each transition strategic rather than desperate.

In each case, the pull started as a feeling—something was missing, there had to be more. But feelings alone aren’t enough to make smart business decisions—your intuition and your numbers are both trying to tell you something.

What I learned was this: your intuition and your numbers are both trying to tell you something. When I finally started treating them as data points, not distractions, that’s when the real clarity came.

I developed a simple process to help me spot those signals early, test ideas safely, and pivot without burning it all down.

The Data-Driven Warning Signs

Don't rely on feelings alone. Track these for 30 days to determine if a pivot is warranted—listening to the whispers before they become screams:

Pay Attention to Your Energy Patterns 

For two weeks, rate each work activity daily (1-10 scale):

• What energized you vs. drained you?
• What do you procrastinate on vs. complete early?
• Which tasks did clients value most?

Pattern recognition is everything. I was procrastinating on coaching content creation, but couldn't wait to research venues for clients—that told me something important.

Notice What People Keep Asking You For 

• How often do people ask for services outside your current offering?
• Unsolicited referrals for different types of work
• Conversations where you have unexpected expertise

When hotel sourcing requests consistently paid 3x my coaching rate with half the effort, I couldn't ignore that data.

Track What Lights You Up vs. What Pays the Bills 

Rate each project on:

• Client satisfaction (how thrilled were they?)
• Your satisfaction (how fulfilled did you feel?)
• Profit margin and effort required

High client satisfaction + high personal satisfaction + good margins + low effort = potential pivot direction.

The 90-Day Validation Process

Before making major changes, validate your hypothesis:

Days 1-30: Research Phase

• Interview at least 10 people in your target market about their frustrations
• Research 5-10 competitors: pricing, gaps, client complaints
• List transferable skills from current and previous careers
• Calculate transition costs and revenue projections

Days 31-60: Testing Phase

• Offer beta services to 3-5 existing clients at a discount
• Write content about your potential new direction and monitor engagement
• Attend industry events and have informational interviews
• Test pricing with different client segments

Days 61-90: Validation Phase

• Create basic processes for the new service
• Build case studies from beta clients
• Compare margins and scalability to the current model
• Make a go/no-go decision based on data, not emotions

Red Flags: When NOT to Pivot

I've seen too many entrepreneurs make expensive mistakes by pivoting for the wrong reasons at the wrong time. Here's what I wish I'd known earlier:

When Financial Pressure is Driving the Timeline. If you're considering a pivot primarily because your current business is struggling financially, pump the brakes. I watched a client try to pivot from struggling freelance writing to real estate because she heard agents made good money. She spent thousands on licensing and training, only to discover she hated cold calling and didn't have the sales personality the job required.

Desperation makes for terrible decision-making. If money pressure is your primary motivator, focus first on stabilizing your current situation before making major changes. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 20% of small businesses fail in their first year, and nearly 50% don’t make it past year five, often because the pivot was reactive, not strategic. Your goal isn’t just to change—it’s to evolve with staying power.

When You Can't Find Your Market. Before I fully committed to hotel sourcing, I spent three months talking to business owners and organizations about the services I would offer. If you can't identify at least 10 potential clients who have the problem you want to solve AND the budget to pay for solutions, stop. The market might not be there, or you might not understand it well enough yet.

One of my colleagues spent a year developing a business around a service no one wanted to buy. Don't let enthusiasm blind you to market realities.

When you're Running Away Rather Than Toward. When your pivot is about escaping current problems rather than pursuing compelling opportunities. I've watched entrepreneurs hop from business to business, thinking each change will solve their fundamental issues with time management, difficult clients, or work-life balance.

But here's the truth: if you're disorganized, struggle with boundaries, or lack systems, those problems will follow you to your new business. Make sure you're running toward something that genuinely excites you, not just away from something that's temporarily difficult.

‍

Your 7-Day Quick Assessment: Should You Explore a Pivot?

Before committing to the full 30-day tracking process, ask yourself these questions to determine if you're ready to seriously consider a change:

Day 1: Energy Check Notice your energy patterns today. What tasks made you feel alive vs. drained? Don't overthink it—just observe.

Day 2: Outside Perspective Ask three trusted people this question: "If you had to describe what I'm naturally great at, what would you say?" Listen for patterns.

Day 3: Financial Reality. Calculate your true monthly expenses (business + personal). Do you have at least 6 months saved? If not, focus on building that buffer before exploring major changes.

Day 4: Market Signal Check Review the past month: How many times did someone ask you for help with something outside your current services? If it's more than three, pay attention.

Day 5: Skills Inventory List your transferable skills from all previous jobs and experiences. What unique combination do you bring that most people don't have?

Day 6: Gut Check Complete this sentence: "I'd be excited to work on _____ even if no one was paying me." If you can't finish that sentence, you're not ready for a pivot.

Day 7: Go/No-Go Decision Based on the past six days, decide: Are you ready to commit to 30 days of serious tracking and exploration? If yes, begin the warning signs tracking process above. If no, that's perfectly fine—revisit this assessment in three months.

What I Learned From Three Pivots

Trust Your Data Over Others' Opinions. People questioned each of my transitions, but the market data was clear. Your hourly rate, energy levels, and client satisfaction don't lie.

Your Previous Experience Is an Asset. My corporate background makes me better at hotel sourcing because I understand business needs. Nothing you've learned is wasted.

Build Bridges, Don't Burn Boats. Each pivot built on the previous one. I maintained relationships and revenue streams while testing new directions.

Start Before You're Ready. I waited too long to act on clear signals. When multiple data points align, move forward with small tests rather than endless analysis.

The Cost of Staying in the wrong situation is always higher than the cost of strategic change. Your business should evolve with you, not trap you.

If you're considering a pivot and want to talk it through, let’s chat over a Virtual Diet Coke or via LinkedIn. I’ve been there, and I’d love to help you spot the signals you might be missing.

‍